Posted by Ask a Manager
https://www.askamanager.org/2025/12/updates-2-employees-dislike-each-other-scolded-for-eavesdropping-and-more.html
https://www.askamanager.org/?p=34803
It’s “where are you now?” month at Ask a Manager, and all December I’m running updates from people who had their letters here answered in the past. Here are four updates from past letter-writers.
1. How do I manage petty behavior between two employees who dislike each other?
For context, I am not the manager of either of these employees, just an innocent bystander trying to help the manager figure this out.
The feedback that was given to both of these employees was relatively similar to what you suggested. Basically, the manager focused not on the specific incidents, but instead on telling these employees that the expectation is that they treat all coworkers with professionalism and respect, and focus on having collaborative relationships with everyone on the team. Even if there was some “but [other coworker] did this…” pushback, the manager kept returning to what the expectations were. The manager has also done a great job at reassessing and rebuilding their relationships with all their employees and creating more appropriate boundaries in the manager/employee relationship.
Overall, things have definitely gotten better. I have personally seen these two individuals interact in a very friendly manner on at least one occasion. Basically, it’s become more than clear that one employee was actually the instigator the whole time, and it was affecting the team more than the manager realized. Now that dynamics are changing and some unrelated situations have come to light, it’s obvious that there really is only one problem employee and the communication and judgement issues stem to other parts of their work as well.
For a long time, there was the feeling that it would be devastating to lose this employee, but after all of this, the manager is prepared to lose this employee if their behavior doesn’t improve. Luckily, with the new-found appropriately professional boundaries and continued coaching, it seems like the employee is more willing to take feedback to heart, so a win for all involved!
2. I got scolded for “eavesdropping” when I asked about a task that would involve me
You and all the commenters’ advice helped me so much! I read through every comment and it gave me a lot to think about, as well as some great advice for next steps. I agree with the commenters who said that I probably should have waited for my officemate to bring the issue to me and that I should have ignored what I heard. But, I also agree that my overstep shouldn’t have been met with such an extreme response.
Alison, you hit the nail on the head when you said that something in my office is rotten, and apparently my HR reps agree!
A few days after the eavesdropping event, I ended up having some other issues with the same coworker about a long term project. Despite trying all the conflict resolution and communication tools at my disposal, as well as talking with my manager, the issues persisted. I ended up going to my organization’s HR department with all my documentation because I knew how much this project was going to reflect onto my yearly review. The HR reps were incredibly supportive and in fact, agreed that my department’s culture has been a known issue for some time. Apparently my position’s predecessor reported the same issues before leaving the organization. They advised me to continue documenting, that my yearly review would not be impacted by this, and that they would provide me with references or mediation if needed.
So, I’m planning my exit. I have some great coworkers in other departments who were willing to come to bat for me and offered to come talk to HR with me. They’ve also said they’re keeping me in mind for a transfer if a position opens up. However, I’m excited by the prospect of professionally growing somewhere else. I want to particularly shout out commenter Ally McBeal who advised me to be aware of recalibrating to less toxic environments. Until I leave this pressure cooker, the headphones are staying on and I’m keeping my head down low.
3. Employee runs to work and drips water and mud everywhere when he arrives
Since I wrote, there have been a couple of changes that effectively solved the problems for us. Development in our area added some new paved paths so no more muddiness (and no more dropped underpants!). Our team now includes some full-time-remote folks so many more of our meetings are online, meaning shivering is no longer of concern. We did have to get Leonard to make sure to turn his heater off during online meetings, as the sound was causing some interference, but he has done that without complaint.
Thanks for the advice!
4. Should I say something to the coworker crying in the bathroom?
I had been thinking about what to say to a potential bathroom crier on and off for weeks, but since I wrote in there was only one instance of someone crying in the bathroom. They sounded like they were trying to hold it in, and I chickened out and did nothing.
Thinking it over now, the commenters who advocated for a cone of silence are probably right, at least when the crying is happening in a stall.
The post updates: 2 employees dislike each other, scolded for “eavesdropping,” and more appeared first on Ask a Manager.
https://www.askamanager.org/2025/12/updates-2-employees-dislike-each-other-scolded-for-eavesdropping-and-more.html
https://www.askamanager.org/?p=34803